A DUI arrest often begins long before a driver is placed in handcuffs. From the moment a police officer notices a vehicle on the road, that officer may begin looking for evidence of impaired driving. But what many drivers don’t realize is that DUI investigations typically follow a specific process, and the officer’s actions throughout that process can have a significant impact on the case.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) trains law enforcement officers to recognize and investigate suspected impaired driving through three phases of a DUI investigation: vehicle in motion, personal contact, and pre-arrest screening.
Each phase serves a different purpose. Officers gather observations and evidence to determine whether further investigation or an arrest is justified. However, an officer’s suspicions do not automatically establish that someone was driving under the influence.
Understanding these three phases can help Tennessee drivers recognize why the details of a DUI investigation matter and how an experienced DUI defense attorney may identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case.
Phase 1: Vehicle in Motion — Why Did the Officer Stop You?
The first phase of a DUI investigation typically begins when an officer observes a vehicle being driven. During this phase, officers look for driving behaviors that might suggest impairment and decide whether there is a lawful reason to initiate a traffic stop.
What Driving Behaviors Do Police Look for?
According to NHTSA’s standardized field sobriety testing training materials, officers are trained to recognize a variety of driving cues that may be associated with impairment.
Common examples include:
- Difficulty maintaining lane position: Weaving, drifting, swerving, or crossing lane markings.
- Speed and braking problems: Unusually slow driving, inconsistent speeds, or unnecessary braking.
- Problems with vigilance: Delayed reactions to traffic signals, driving without headlights, or failing to respond appropriately to roadway conditions.
- Poor judgment: Unsafe turns, following too closely, or other potentially dangerous maneuvers.
Officers may also observe how a driver responds when emergency lights are activated, including whether the driver recognizes the signal and pulls over safely.
However, these observations must be evaluated in context. A driver might drift within a lane because of road conditions, briefly lose concentration, or make an ordinary driving mistake. Such behavior does not necessarily mean the driver is impaired.
When Is a DUI Traffic Stop Legal in Tennessee?
Under Tennessee law, an officer generally needs a legally sufficient basis to stop a vehicle, such as reasonable suspicion of criminal activity or an observed traffic violation.
Reasonable suspicion requires specific, articulable facts that objectively justify an officer’s suspicion. A mere hunch is not enough.
For example, an officer who observes a driver committing a traffic violation may lawfully stop the vehicle even without initially suspecting DUI. However, the fact that someone was speeding or committed another traffic offense does not automatically establish that the person was impaired.
Tennessee courts have also recognized that minor imperfections in driving do not always justify a DUI investigation. In State v. Binette, the Tennessee Supreme Court concluded that a driver’s relatively slight movement within a lane did not establish reasonable suspicion sufficient to justify the traffic stop.
An experienced DUI defense attorney will examine the officer’s observations, the alleged reason for the stop, and available video evidence to determine whether the stop was lawful.
For a more detailed examination, read our article on the vehicle in motion phase of a DUI investigation.
Phase 2: Personal Contact — What Happens When an Officer Approaches Your Vehicle?
The second phase begins when the officer makes personal contact with the driver.
During this interaction, the officer is trained to observe the driver’s appearance, behavior, speech, and responses for possible signs of impairment. These observations may influence whether the officer believes further DUI investigation is warranted.
What Signs of Impairment Do Officers Look for?
Common observations documented during the personal contact phase include:
- The odor of an alcoholic beverage
- Bloodshot, red, or watery eyes
- Slurred or unusual speech
- Difficulty retrieving a driver’s license or registration
- Unsteady movements or apparent coordination problems
- Statements about consuming alcohol or drugs
Officers may ask questions about where a driver is coming from, whether they have consumed alcohol, or how much they have had to drink.
However, there is an important distinction between evidence that someone consumed alcohol and evidence that someone was impaired by alcohol.
Does the Smell of Alcohol Prove Someone Was Driving Under the Influence?
No. The odor of an alcoholic beverage may indicate that alcohol was consumed, but it does not, by itself, establish how much alcohol someone consumed or whether their ability to drive was impaired.
Other commonly cited observations can also have explanations unrelated to intoxication.
For example, bloodshot or watery eyes may result from allergies, contact lenses, fatigue, or environmental conditions. Nervousness during a police encounter can affect someone’s speech or behavior, while an injury or medical condition may explain apparent difficulties with balance or coordination.
These possibilities do not mean an officer must disregard potential signs of impairment. Rather, the observations should be considered together with the other available evidence.
Can Police Extend a Traffic Stop to Investigate DUI?
This is one of the most important legal issues that can arise during the personal contact phase.
Suppose an officer stops someone for a broken taillight. The officer can investigate that traffic violation, but the original reason for the stop does not automatically authorize an unrelated, prolonged DUI investigation.
To extend the detention beyond the time reasonably necessary to complete the original traffic-stop mission, the officer generally must have independent reasonable suspicion of additional criminal activity.
For example, if the officer develops reasonable suspicion of impairment during the interaction, additional investigation may be justified. Without sufficient justification, however, prolonging the encounter could violate the driver’s constitutional rights.
At Barnes & Fersten, we examine the officer’s observations and the sequence of events to determine whether a lawful traffic stop was improperly extended. Our attorneys explain this in more detail in our article on the personal contact phase and the importance of challenging evidence.
Phase 3: Pre-Arrest Screening — Field Sobriety Tests and the Arrest Decision
If an officer believes there is sufficient reason to continue investigating possible impairment, the encounter may proceed to the third phase: pre-arrest screening.
This phase commonly involves asking the driver to perform standardized field sobriety tests (SFSTs). The officer uses the driver’s performance, along with observations from the earlier phases, to determine whether probable cause exists to make a DUI arrest.
What Are the Three Standardized Field Sobriety Tests?
NHTSA recognizes three standardized field sobriety tests:
1. Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN)
During the HGN test, an officer asks the driver to follow a moving object, such as a pen or fingertip, with their eyes. The officer looks for specific involuntary eye movements that may be associated with alcohol impairment.
However, certain medical conditions and other factors can affect eye movements, and the proper administration and interpretation of this test are important considerations.
2. Walk-and-Turn Test
The walk-and-turn test requires a driver to take a series of heel-to-toe steps along a straight line, turn according to specific instructions, and return.
Officers evaluate several potential clues, including difficulty maintaining balance, stepping off the line, taking an incorrect number of steps, or failing to follow instructions.
3. One-Leg Stand Test
During this test, the driver is instructed to stand on one leg while counting aloud until told to stop. The officer observes potential clues such as swaying, hopping, using the arms for balance, or putting the raised foot down.
These tests are designed to assess possible impairment, including difficulties with balance, coordination, and divided attention. However, performing poorly on a field sobriety test does not necessarily establish that someone was driving under the influence.
Why Field Sobriety Tests Can Be Challenged
Standardized field sobriety tests are intended to be administered according to established procedures. Their results may be affected by how the officer provides instructions, demonstrates the tests, or evaluates the driver’s performance.
Other circumstances can also influence the results, including:
- Uneven, sloped, or slippery testing surfaces
- Poor lighting or unfavorable weather conditions
- Physical injuries or medical conditions
- Balance disorders or mobility limitations
- Fatigue, nervousness, or difficulty understanding instructions
For example, someone experiencing chronic knee pain may have difficulty standing on one leg regardless of whether they consumed alcohol. Similarly, a driver may misunderstand an instruction or struggle to maintain balance on an uneven roadside surface.
These circumstances do not automatically invalidate a test, but they may affect how much weight its results should receive.
Our attorneys examine whether field sobriety tests were properly administered and whether the alleged clues of impairment are supported by the evidence. Read more about standardized field sobriety tests in Tennessee.
Are Field Sobriety Tests Mandatory in Tennessee?
No. Standardized roadside field sobriety tests are generally voluntary in Tennessee, and drivers are not required to perform them. Additionally, there is no penalty for refusing field sobriety tests in Tennessee.
However, refusing field sobriety tests does not necessarily prevent an arrest. An officer may still determine that probable cause exists based on other observations and evidence.
It is also important to distinguish field sobriety tests from chemical breath and blood testing, which are governed by Tennessee’s implied consent law and involve different legal considerations and potential consequences.
What Establishes Probable Cause for a DUI Arrest?
Before making a DUI arrest, an officer must have probable cause to believe the driver committed the offense.
Probable cause is a higher legal standard than reasonable suspicion. It requires sufficient facts and circumstances to support a reasonable belief that an offense has occurred.
When evaluating probable cause, the officer may consider evidence gathered throughout the investigation, including driving behavior, physical observations, statements, field sobriety test performance, and other relevant information.
Importantly, an officer does not necessarily need to administer field sobriety tests before making a DUI arrest. An arrest may still be lawful if the totality of the circumstances establishes probable cause.
Conversely, evidence gathered during the investigation may be insufficient to justify an arrest, even when the officer believes the driver was impaired.
What Happens After the Three Phases of a DUI Investigation?
The three-phase framework describes the process officers use to detect suspected impairment and decide whether an arrest is justified. However, an investigation does not necessarily end when someone is arrested.
Officers may seek additional evidence through breath or blood testing to determine a driver’s blood alcohol concentration or identify the presence of drugs.
Under Tennessee Code § 55-10-406, the state’s implied consent law governs important aspects of chemical testing in DUI investigations.
Refusing a lawfully requested breath or blood test can result in separate consequences, including the loss of driving privileges. Depending on the circumstances, law enforcement may also obtain a search warrant authorizing a blood draw.
Chemical test evidence can be important to a DUI prosecution, but questions about the legality of the testing, the procedures used, and the reliability of the results may also become important defense issues.
Learn more about Tennessee’s implied consent law.
Why Every Phase of a DUI Investigation Matters to Your Defense
When someone is charged with DUI, it can be tempting to focus exclusively on the result of a breath or blood test. However, defending a DUI case requires examining much more than a reported blood alcohol concentration.
A DUI investigation should be evaluated from the officer’s first observations through the decision to make an arrest and collect additional evidence.
At Barnes & Fersten, our DUI defense attorneys examine each phase of the investigation to identify potential legal and evidentiary issues.
That examination may include determining:
- Whether the officer had a lawful reason to initiate the traffic stop
- Whether reasonable suspicion existed to extend the encounter into a DUI investigation
- Whether the officer’s observations were consistent with impairment or had other reasonable explanations
- Whether field sobriety tests were properly administered and evaluated
- Whether sufficient probable cause existed to justify the arrest
- Whether breath or blood testing complied with applicable legal requirements
We also examine available evidence, including dash camera footage, body camera recordings, police reports, witness statements, and chemical testing records.
A police report may describe a driver’s behavior as suspicious, but video footage or other evidence may tell a more complete story. Differences between an officer’s written account and what actually occurred can become significant when evaluating the strength of the prosecution’s case.
Constitutional violations, improperly obtained evidence, or weaknesses in the prosecution’s proof may provide grounds to challenge evidence, negotiate a favorable resolution, or pursue dismissal when legally justified.
Every DUI case is different. A thorough investigation helps identify the defense strategy best suited to the facts and circumstances.
Facing a DUI Charge in Knoxville? Contact Barnes & Fersten
A DUI arrest does not mean a conviction is inevitable. From the initial traffic stop to the officer’s decision to make an arrest, every phase of a DUI investigation deserves careful examination.
At Barnes & Fersten, our attorneys understand how law enforcement officers are trained to investigate suspected impaired driving and how to identify potential weaknesses in the evidence against you. We work to protect our clients’ constitutional rights and pursue the best possible outcome based on their individual circumstances.
If you are facing DUI charges in Knoxville or elsewhere in East Tennessee, our team is prepared to evaluate your case and explain your options. Contact Barnes & Fersten today by calling 865-805-5703 or by filling out our contact form to schedule a free consultation.
Attorney At Law, Managing Partner
Brandon D. Fersten is an esteemed Knoxville attorney practicing DUI, criminal defense, and juvenile law. Known for his empathetic approach and commitment to his clients, he brings a record of favorable case outcomes including dismissals and not guilty verdicts at jury trials resulting in Brandon being recognized as one of the “Top 40 Under 40” in Criminal Defense, U.S. News’ Best Lawyers: “Ones to Watch,” and Super Lawyers’ “Rising Stars”. Brandon’s professional accolades, combined with his passion for justice, position him as a reliable criminal defense advocate in the East Tennessee legal landscape, including Knox County, Blount County, Sevier County, Loudon County, Roane County, Anderson County, Cumberland County, Hamblen County, Monroe County, and McMinn County.